Sotelo Mexican Restaurant
About This Spot
Walking into Sotelo Mexican Restaurant feels like stepping into a warm, familiar corner of St. Joseph where time slows down just enough to savor the rhythms of everyday life. This modest, no-frills spot hums quietly with the steady cadence of friendly conversations and the comforting clatter of dishes. It’s not polished or flashy, but there’s a genuine heart that pulses behind every meal served here.
The atmosphere is unhurried and inviting—a neighborhood haven where locals gather for flavors that remind them of home. The pace is casual, marked by attentive, down-to-earth service that balances efficiency with warmth. It’s the kind of place where kindness and a shared love for authentic, carefully crafted Mexican food quietly shape the experience.
The menu unfolds like a heartfelt story told through familiar, lovingly prepared dishes. Whether it’s the rich, slow-cooked depth found in the menudo or the vibrant zest of street tacos, each bite carries a sense of tradition and care. Homemade tortillas, fresh salsas, and generous portions invite you to relax and linger, paired perfectly with a classic Mexican Coca Cola or a cold beer when the day calls for it.
More than just a meal, dining at Sotelo is an intimate glimpse into a local rhythm that prizes honest flavors over flash, and a sense of belonging over fuss. It’s a humble refuge where everyday moments become a little more meaningful through food shared and enjoyed together.
What’s Available Here
-
No-contact delivery
-
Delivery
-
Takeaway
-
Dine-in
-
Alcohol
-
Cocktails
-
Coffee
-
Comfort food
-
Small plates
-
Vegetarian options
-
Breakfast
-
Lunch
-
Dinner
-
Dessert
-
Seating
-
Table service
-
Bar on site
-
Toilet
-
Family friendly
-
Accepts reservations
-
Debit cards
-
NFC mobile payments
-
Credit cards
-
Good for kids
-
High chairs
-
Kids' menu
-
Free parking lot
-
Parking
-
Dogs allowed outside
Rique L 18 Dec 2025
As far as food quality I'll give it a 4. It tastes homemade with a bit more attention to flavor vs other Mexican restaurants. The portions vs the price was a 5. And even though the place is small and not as appealing, I would visit again someday.
Francisco Gortes 22 Nov 2025
Sotelo is the most authentic Mexican diner in St. Joseph. My wife ordered street tacos which were delectable. The carne asada is the best. I ordered the lunch fajita trio and the portions were very generous. Washing it all down with a Mexican Coca Cola was the proverbial icing on the cake.
EROK -THA FOODIE 05 Nov 2025
I'm only reviewing the Menudo at this time. It is sooo good and the flavor is spot on. It's not really hot or spicy but the flavor is awesome. Comes with choice of corn or flour tortillas, limes and cilantro and onion. And i felt 100% better after eating this. The large is little spendy but worth it. $15.
Daniel Lopez 02 Nov 2025
Menudo was super good, and the homemade corn tortillas were amazing. If you in the St. Joe area looking for good mexican food give them a try. Oh yeah, chips and hot sauce are good.
Karen Kepka 01 Nov 2025
This is TRULY my fav Mexican restaurant. The food is authentic Mexican. I’ve had several of the food on their menu and the Pina Veracruzana is my absolute favorite. We’ve always gotten our food served together and with kindness, speed and professionalism. I’d give Sotello’s 20 stars if I could.
dorothy murfin 30 Oct 2025
This is by far my favorite Mexican restaurant in town. I could eat there everyday. Maria is the best and sweetest waitress ever! She remembers us by name every time. They need to improve the kitchen help so they are faster. Regardless, they are the best and are authentic to Mexican food.
Charlotte Fields (Wendy Fields) 21 Oct 2025
I've been there several times now and I'm never disappointed. The food is wonderful and the staff friendly. It is one of my favorite places to eat in St. Joseph.
Eric Flack 16 Sep 2025
This little place is a treat! Fresh and tasty food, large selection on the menu, Spicy if you like or savory, unique or traditional the chips and salsa are excellent, obviously a homemade recipe on the salsa which was great, service is super friendly. It's a cozy neighborhood restaurant feel with a big menu, it will surprise you ! Support these authentic hard working people !